Hello,
I was a career backseater in the club for 10 years before I finally had the $$, stable job, and towing vehicle to finally buy a boat. I got an aluminum because it was cheap, and I could make mistakes without it costing me big bucks. It was a great learning experience overall. Then I upgraded to a new fiberglass boat.
I now own a 520 DVX Ranger Commanche (20' dual console) with a 225 HPDI. The boat has a very smooth, comfortable, dry ride and is built exceptionally well - a trademark of all Ranger boats.
Fuel/oil consumption on the HPDI is very good compared to other fuel injected/carborated engines. Power is excellent and it's very, very quiet. The new Optis and E-Tecs are in the same league and very comparible. I love my Yammie and have been very happy with it.
I haven't had any experience with Nixon's, but Spokane Valley Marine has treated me very, very well - even performing repairs, or delivering parts in person, at tournament locations. I had a bad battery when I bought it, and they not only upgraded me to a larger battery for free, but they installed it at Banks lake, then performed a factory upgrade on the control panel while they were at it.
In addition, Ranger boats headquarters has also provided exceptional service. My cover was causing wear marks on the gelcoat from trailering so I gave them a call. I ended up talking to the woman who made my cover, explained to her the problem, and she said in her southern drawl, "Send it over to me, honey, I'll take care of it." 10 days later I had a felt-lined cover delivered to my doorstep, free of charge.
I can go on and on, but you get the jist.
Ownership pride aside, I can confidentally say from my experience as a backseater, stick with the major, familiar brand names and you'll be fine. Follow Chris' advice, and carefully examine fit/finish ( a good quality test is to run your hand underneath the livewell lip - quality boats finish it, cheap boats don't). The quality of the trim/finish work can give insight into how the rest of the boat is built.
Are you and buddy just going to fish, or is the whole family? If mom and the kids are in tow, then getting a Comanche 520SVX with a 225 Mercury OptiMax on the back probably isn't the best choice. At that point a good compromise is a play and ski boat or a boat with plenty of freeboard (read: tall sides) to help keep the kids safely in the boat when it gets windy and the waves kick up.
When looking at a boat, I think a person should consider the following three things:
- Is this a boat you would be happy with for awhile - does it have what you want, where you want it? This is an obvious but sometimes overlooked item - especially with the thrill of the hunt and people become enamored with the shiny metal flake finish and forget that the rod locker isn't long enough for their beloved 9'8" Muskie Masher rod. Get in the boat with the dealer rep and look around - sit in the seats and check things out. You can quickly determine whether a model fits your needs.
- Look at the fit and finish. This is a tell-tale sign of quality. Check to see how the carpet is put in - especially around the hatches. A sloppy job there usually speaks volumes. Step on the hatches - are they really bouncy? That's not good either. Look at the compartments - are they plastic, metal or fiberglass and how are they put in? One of the things Dan at Spokane Valley Marine did in the fiberglass Rangers is jump down inside one of the back storage compartments to show how strong they are and how integrated they are into the boat. And at 250 pounds, that's some pretty good weight going into that compartment - without a problem.
- What do you get for your money? Look at the features and compare. Are they including a standard model locator or an upgrade? The same goes for the trolling motor. Also look at the little things that mean a lot… like a 1000 GPH bilge pump (rather than 500 or 750 - how bad do you want to bail in a storm or emergency?!), six gauge wiring instead of ten or eight (heavier wire means more power goes from the battery to your locator, trolling motor, etc.).
Check out the trailer. If you will be handling the boat by yourself, I would recommend a single axle. If you get a 20-foot or larger boat you will need a tandem axle with brakes. Tandems are hard to move by yourself and the brakes can add to your problems in backing up, but they do pull on the road great. Newer boats have brakes that automatically disengage when you put the truck in reverse.
Another thing to consider is the quality and value, which can be seen in the resale value of a boat. Check out an ABOS Blue Book on your favorite brands and see the median value of the one-year old models - especially if it's a model you are considering. These numbers can be really enlightening.
Finally, grab a handful of rods and some tackle, take it out on the water, and fish it. How well can you maneuver on the deck without tripping over your rods? If your fishing spot is the back deck, how big is the area and is the seat comfortable? If you share the front deck, is the deck area large enough for two to fish comfortably? Does the butt seat have more than one seat-mounting hole to give you flexibility in fishing area and be able to reach for the trolling motor with ease? Sit down in the driver's seat and see if you can see the gauges. Does the steering wheel tilt, can you see over the dash to drive and is the seat comfortable for long runs down the lake to that hot spot? How well can you view the front depthfinder when fishing both sides? If it 's a used boat, is there electronic interference showing up on the depthfinder? Is the trolling motor adequate for handling the boat? How well does the motor start? And of course, drive the thing - it's very, very different from your current boat!
Pick a somewhat windy day. Any boat will run good on a smooth surface, but how does it do in real conditions?
Believe it or not, there are many subtle nuances to boat handling, and not just learning to launch and retrieve your boat, or backing down the ramp. When I was first learning to handle my Ranger I had a difficult time, especially with learning the sublties of using the trim while racing down the lake. When I first had my aluminum, putting the boat back onto the trailer took awhile to learn. I was lucky that a Ranger pro-staffer was able to help me learn how to drive the boat. He went out with me and taught me in 1 hour what would have taken me long time, and probably lots of repairs to find out. He taught me to listen for the pitch change when trimming down, how to handle crossing wakes, and much more. I'm sure the many club members would do the same for you, so don't be afraid to ask. Everyone had to learn somehow, and I haven't met a boat owner yet that wasn't willing to help someone learn.
By all means, common sense will tell you that if you become uncomfortable at some point with your selection, don't make the deal. You're making a major investment and need to shop hard to get the best deal. Awesome boat deals are abundant. If you miss out on one, there's no doubt another is right around the corner.
Buying a boat is an exciting time, and whether you buy a new or used boat, I know you'll enjoy your time on the water. Good luck and good fishing.